Legal studies assessment human trafficking and

Indeed, the significant numerical increase witnessed during the fiscal year, which is far more than the number of visas that had been granted during the preceding five years, might be taken as indicative of the relative success of the amendment in terms of offering more protection to victims.

They are, therefore, less appealing and helpful in ameliorating the immediate needs of the victims. Consequently, with the view of avoiding or reducing a potential burden arising out of the treatment of such persons, states may be tempted into deliberately misidentifying trafficked persons as smuggled people.

Police training for rank and file officers largely consists of a minute e-learning module on trafficking, within which just two screens relate to Section Article 3 a of the Trafficking Protocol defines trafficking in persons as: the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payment or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person for the purpose of exploitation emphasis added.

Legal studies human rights assessment task

Australia has ratified the Trafficking Protocol, therefore, it is obliged to criminalize trafficking offences as defined under Article 3 a. Any such reforms should also consider the allocation of proportionate attention and resources to both sexual and labour trafficking offences. A Visa Frameworks 1 Bridging Visa F This visa category is applicable to persons identified as suspected victims of trafficking who cannot access other valid visas to allow them to legally stay in Australia. Any absence of these elements would have the negative repercussion of conflating the two distinct criminal activities. One of the major objectives is to promote efforts among member states to provide protection and assistance through, amongst others, the granting of residency permits to victims. This promotes the effectiveness of law enforcement efforts. Consequently, with the view of avoiding or reducing a potential burden arising out of the treatment of such persons, states may be tempted into deliberately misidentifying trafficked persons as smuggled people. Having discussed the definitions and the nexus between trafficking and smuggling offences as a background, the gist of the trafficking definition under the Australian Criminal Code will be discussed in the next section. See sections For instance, from 1 January - 30 June Bridging Visa F, 76 Criminal Justice Visas, 17 witness Protection temporary visas and 2 witness Protection permanent visas were granted. Australia ratified this protocol on 11 Sep Victim assistance programs, such as rehabilitation and residency permits must be properly considered alongside the criminalisation of the practices and apprehension of offenders. A further six cases pending before the courts. A law enforcement approach that hinges on the apprehension and punishment of perpetrators plays a pivotal role in this regard. It follows that fraud, force or coercion all play a major role in trafficking emphasis added.

Of this number, 39 were referred to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions CDPP and charged, leading to nine convictions and five cases still pending before the courts.

However, in practice the distinction between the two offences might be very blurred. The indications are that the UK is sincere in its drive to support victims of modern slavery and that Section 45 is not the result of mere lip service. Thus, while trafficking involves consent nullifying action sit is for the purpose of exploitation and it does not necessarily involve transnational elements.

In this regard, the Australian counterpart is often criticised for leaving labour trafficking offences in the periphery.

Among others, the exploitation of the victims is what distinguishes trafficking from smuggling and other irregular migrations.

hsc legal studies human rights assessment task

Nevertheless, in disregard of this evidence, authorities sent her to an immigration detention centre. Nevertheless, exacerbated by its clandestine nature, the absence of reliable and comprehensive data on the extent and nature of the problem hinders both the appreciation of the true magnitude of the problem and the making of appropriate policies and legislative reforms.

History of human trafficking pdf

Implementation This raft of measures is meant to end the double victimisation of those who suffer first at the hands of traffickers and then at the hands of the state. The Human Smuggling and Trafficking Centre summarises the distinction between the two illicit practices as: [U]nlike smuggling, which is often a criminal commercial transaction between two willing parties who go their separate ways once their business is complete, trafficking specifically targets the trafficked person as an object of criminal exploitation. Consequently, both law enforcement and human right paradigms are necessary to fight the problem. They are, therefore, less appealing and helpful in ameliorating the immediate needs of the victims. As a result, the human rights and other basic needs of the victims are obscured or at least lacking appropriate attention. Regarding law enforcement actions on the ground, the Anti People Trafficking Interdepartmental Committee recently reported that, as of June , the Australian Federal Police AFP has conducted investigations and assessments pertaining to trafficking offences. This post considers whether UK law is providing protections for this largely hidden and voiceless population, many of them children.
Rated 7/10 based on 48 review
Download
Trafficking in Persons & Smuggling of Migrants Module 6 Key Issues: International legal framework